Sunday, March 27, 2011

Reflections on EDLD 5301 Action Research


        Action Research was a term that was unfamiliar to me before this course.  Five weeks later, I have not only learned about action research, but have embraced it and look forward to completing my first action research project.  Several of the lectures, activities, readings as well as blog reflections and discussion posts have all contributed to my transformation into an action researcher.  
       Several highlights provided insight for me in regards to action research. One highlight was completing the Action Planning Template (Tool 7-1).  The process of completing this template required me to think through my action research project in great detail and to designate specific information that will allow for a successful process in research.  Reflecting on goals, resources, timelines, responsible persons, evaluation etc. provided valuable insight into my project.
       Another highlight of this course was learning to create and post on a blog.  The process of completing the blog assignments and posting my reflections on the blog have allowed me to reflect on my project on a regular basis.  Writing my thoughts provides me a deeper reflection and understanding of the project and allows for others to provide useful feedback. 
       One major highlight occurred with a response to my week 1 discussion post.  The response was from Pamela Huggins who is a Career Tech teacher.  She noted similarities between fine arts courses and CTE courses in that both are non-core areas.  She provided her thoughts concerning her subject in relation to my topic and how she thought it would also apply to fine arts.  Pamela indicates that students are practicing listening skills, study habits, and meeting deadlines with many non-core classes.  She also states  “there are many areas that relate back to core subjects and testing that then when needed they can transfer that information to whatever subject it comes up in again.”  From this comment, I decided to include research and literature on the transfer and application of fine arts courses to core classes.  I also decided to include questions on my surveys that ask participants to describe how fine arts courses help students with skills related to learning.  Both revisions to my research approach were as a result of the discussion post from Pamela. Her post was extremely helpful and provided reflection in an area that I had not previously considered.
       Many of the required readings provided great insight, however one in particular was especially interesting and helpful to me in regards to action research.  In her book “Leading with Passion and Knowledge: The Principal as Action Researcher”, Nancy Fitchman Dana facilitates the process of “Finding a Wondering” in Chapter 2 “Passions That Drive Your Journey”.  The chapter outlines nine areas of passion where an administrator might find his or her first wondering.  The chapter uses several examples to illustrate each passion.  Each of the examples helped me to relate to the information by putting a face and scenario to the material.  I really enjoyed this chapter and was able to better understand the process of developing your inquiry or wondering. 
       Finally, I really enjoyed the lecture that included interviews with three school leaders who use action research.  The highlight of this lecture was the interview with Dr. Kirk Lewis, Superintendent of the Pasadena Independent School District.  Dr. Lewis details an action research project in his district that is funded by a Bill and Melinda Gates school improvement grant.  The project is titled “Expectation Graduation”.  This project was initially designed towards 9th graders to “get them in line and processed towards graduation”.  The projects primary design is to change the way teachers deliver instruction to insure that students understanding at a deeper level.  The project also focuses how the district can make core curriculum more rigorous.  In the past, I often considered research as a process that was primarily practiced at the university level.  Dr. Lewis helped to reinforce the idea that research is for all educators and not uncommon in many districts.
       As many have mentioned on the discussion posts, this class was an unexpected pleasure.  Many of us were anticipating a traditional research class and had preconceived ideas about the course.  As we participated in the activities and lectures, we soon learned that research could be interesting and personal and could provide useful results that would provide a clear path for positive change in our own schools.  I have learned how to be an action researcher and look forward to practicing action research for many years.

Sunday, March 20, 2011

Action Research Update/Revisions

After conferencing with my site supervisor and reviewing all peer comments, I have posted an update of my action research plan template.  This update includes one revision suggested by my site supervisor.  She suggested revising action step 10 to specify that the same fine arts disciplines at all 7 schools would receive the student surveys.  She felt that it was important to keep the control the same for comparisons.  Meaning, do not survey art students at one high school and band students at another.  Instead, survey all band or all art or both at all schools.  This would allow for better accuracy.  She also thought this revision might lead to data that is interesting for future inquiry.  For example, do band students respond differently than art students?  Is there a pattern of thought and perception that is consistent within fine arts discipline and are there differences between the disciplines? Her insight was extremely helpful and provided needed clarity.




Action Planning Template (Tool 7.1)

Goal:   To determine the impact of fine arts students on school performance.
                                        Person(s)                    Timeline                       Needed
        Action Steps            Responsible                Start/End                     Resources                Evaluation
1. Discuss Action Research topics with site supervisor
Mark Chambers 
Diana Schumacher
02/28/2011 –
03/04/2011
School Data
Intern Plan
Establish an Action Research question
2. Gather and organize data concerning discipline referrals, school attendance, TAKS scores, SAT/ACT scores.
Mark Chambers
NEISD Research and Information Technologies
Mike Lara (Executive Director, Research and Information Technologies
3/28/2011 –
08/22/2011
School Data
Go Arts – advocacy research group
Evaluate data to look at statistics in relation to fine arts and non fine arts students
3. Gather and organize data concerning class rankings, and college scholarships
Mark Chambers
School Counselors at NEISD seven comprehensive high schools
3/28/2011 –
08/22/2011
Counselor data at NEISD seven comprehensive high schools
Evaluate data to look at statistics in relation to fine arts and non fine arts students
4. Meet with NEISD fine arts teachers to explain Action Research to establish procedures for class evaluations
Mark Chambers
NEISD Fine Arts Teachers
4/14/2011
EDLD 5301 Materials
Power Point on Inquiry/Action Research
Survey teachers to see if they are willing assist in research by allowing class observations and taking a survey
5. Meet with principals of all 7 high schools to seek permission to administer surveys to their teachers and fine arts students
Mark Chambers
HS Principals (Bill Boyd, Jeff Vaughan, Bobbi Turnbo, Rick Canales, Michael Cardona, Chris Thompson,
4/07/2011
Meeting Room
Brochure outlining Action Research inquiry, process and plan for sharing information
Determine if principals will assist with research by participating in a survey and allowing an electronic survey to be distributed to their faculty
6. Determine my own thoughts and assessments by reflecting on past experiences
Mark Chambers

March 2011
Personal journal entries
Videos

Evaluate objectivity in regards to my conducting this topic
7. Develop a survey that assesses feelings and perceptions of administrators, teachers and students concerning fine arts student’s impact on school performance
Mark Chambers
Diana Schumacher
Joseph Johnson
3/28/2011 –
4/05/2011
Survey Monkey
Previous surveys concerning similar topics


8. Review current literature and statistics regarding Action Research topic as well as NEISD data from previous years
Mark Chambers
TMEA
Joseph Johnson (NEISD)
Mike Lara (NEISD)

Spring 2011
TMEA (Texas Music Educators Association) resource dept.
Go Arts.org (Arts advocacy organization
School Data
Evaluate data from previous years to see if it is consistent with current data and how it correlates with data from previous literature
9. Electronically distribute Administrator and teacher survey
Mark Chambers
4/20/2011
E-mail contacts for all participating in survey
Evaluate survey results
10. Distribute student survey to each of the classes at the 7 high schools previous mentioned.  Classes chosen for the survey will be the same sample at each high school.
Mark Chambers

Teachers and students of the 7 selected schools and classes
May 2011
Survey forms, collection envelope, pens
Evaluate survey results
11. Disaggregate information
Mark Chambers
Joseph Johnson (NEISD)
Mike Lara (NEISD)

June 2011 – August 2011
Completed surveys
Computer spreadsheets and graph programs
Review and reflect on disaggregated information to determine if revisions to process are necessary
12. Create document with conclusion and recommendations for future research
Mark Chambers
Diana Schumacher (site supervisor)
August 2011
All data
Examples of other conclusion papers
Distribute paper with selected reviewers to provide feedback before results are distributed
13. Present Conclusion to Principals, Executive staff, teachers, parents and students as well as colleagues in the arts community.  Some presentations will be oral and others will be written or electronic
Mark Chambers
NEISD stakeholders
TMEA
Tom Waggoner (Fine Arts, TEA)
TMAC (Texas Music Administrators Conference)
Start of 2011-2012 Academic year (late August/early September)
Power Point
Brochure with main points
Blogs
E-mail blasts
Website

Observe and evaluate reactions to information.  Determine if perceptions change or remain the same
14. Determine if follow-up research is needed or if more questions develop as a result of the action research project
Mark Chambers
Diana Schumacher
Arts Leaders
NEISD Stakeholders
September 2011
New wonderings
Brainstorm



Sunday, March 13, 2011

Action Research Plan Draft


After several weeks of reflecting, discussing and reviewing my topic for inquiry, I have developed a draft of my action research project.  I followed the process learned in EDLD 5301.  The draft is presented below using the Action Planning Template (Tool 7.1) from the Harris text. (p. 85)
I have listed the goal, action steps, responsible persons, timelines, resources, and processes of evaluation.  I will be collecting data to include multiple standardized statistics as well as administrator, teacher and student surveys.  I will also include interviews and previous literature concerning this topic.  
Various school district personnel as well as some out of district experts will participate as responsible persons in this research.  All needed resources are available and feasible. 
Reflection on the process will take place on a consistent basis and information will be disaggregated and assessed to provide insight on the topic.  Revisions will be determined from this assessment and reflection if necessary.  
Sharing of the results of this project will include the four critical tasks as described in the Dana text.  
Project results will be shared in a creative visual and performing arts format that includes written and oral communication.

Action Planning Template (Tool 7.1)

Goal:   To determine the impact of fine arts students on school performance.
                                        Person(s)                    Timeline                       Needed
        Action Steps            Responsible                Start/End                     Resources                Evaluation
1. Discuss Action Research topics with site supervisor
Mark Chambers 
Diana Schumacher
02/28/2011 –
03/04/2011
School Data
Intern Plan
Establish an Action Research question
2. Gather and organize data concerning discipline referrals, school attendance, TAKS scores, SAT/ACT scores.
Mark Chambers
NEISD Research and Information Technologies
Mike Lara (Executive Director, Research and Information Technologies
3/28/2011 –
08/22/2011
School Data
Go Arts – advocacy research group
Evaluate data to look at statistics in relation to fine arts and non fine arts students
3. Gather and organize data concerning class rankings, and college scholarships
Mark Chambers
School Counselors at NEISD seven comprehensive high schools
3/28/2011 –
08/22/2011
Counselor data at NEISD seven comprehensive high schools
Evaluate data to look at statistics in relation to fine arts and non fine arts students
4. Meet with NEISD fine arts teachers to explain Action Research to establish procedures for class evaluations
Mark Chambers
NEISD Fine Arts Teachers
4/14/2011
EDLD 5301 Materials
Power Point on Inquiry/Action Research
Survey teachers to see if they are willing assist in research by allowing class observations and taking a survey
5. Meet with principals of all 7 high schools to seek permission to administer surveys to their teachers and fine arts students
Mark Chambers
HS Principals (Bill Boyd, Jeff Vaughan, Bobbi Turnbo, Rick Canales, Michael Cardona, Chris Thompson,
4/07/2011
Meeting Room
Brochure outlining Action Research inquiry, process and plan for sharing information
Determine if principals will assist with research by participating in a survey and allowing an electronic survey to be distributed to their faculty
6. Determine my own thoughts and assessments by reflecting on past experiences
Mark Chambers

March 2011
Personal journal entries
Videos

Evaluate objectivity in regards to my conducting this topic
7. Develop a survey that assesses feelings and perceptions of administrators, teachers and students concerning fine arts student’s impact on school performance
Mark Chambers
Diana Schumacher
Joseph Johnson
3/28/2011 –
4/05/2011
Survey Monkey
Previous surveys concerning similar topics


8. Review current literature and statistics regarding Action Research topic as well as NEISD data from previous years
Mark Chambers
TMEA
Joseph Johnson (NEISD)
Mike Lara (NEISD)

Spring 2011
TMEA (Texas Music Educators Association) resource dept.
Go Arts.org (Arts advocacy organization
School Data
Evaluate data from previous years to see if it is consistent with current data and how it correlates with data from previous literature
9. Electronically distribute Administrator and teacher survey
Mark Chambers
4/20/2011
E-mail contacts for all participating in survey
Evaluate survey results
10. Distribute student survey to each of the classes at the 7 high schools previous mentioned.  Classes are inclusive of all of the fine arts disciplines
Mark Chambers

Teachers and students of the 7 selected schools and classes
May 2011
Survey forms, collection envelope, pens
Evaluate survey results
11. Disaggregate information
Mark Chambers
Joseph Johnson (NEISD)
Mike Lara (NEISD)

June 2011 – August 2011
Completed surveys
Computer spreadsheets and graph programs
Review and reflect on disaggregated information to determine if revisions to process are necessary
12. Create document with conclusion and recommendations for future research
Mark Chambers
Diana Schumacher (site supervisor)
August 2011
All data
Examples of other conclusion papers
Distribute paper with selected reviewers to provide feedback before results are distributed
13. Present Conclusion to Principals, Executive staff, teachers, parents and students as well as colleagues in the arts community.  Some presentations will be oral and others will be written or electronic
Mark Chambers
NEISD stakeholders
TMEA
Tom Waggoner (Fine Arts, TEA)
TMAC (Texas Music Administrators Conference)
Start of 2011-2012 Academic year (late August/early September)
Power Point
Brochure with main points
Blogs
E-mail blasts
Website

Observe and evaluate reactions to information.  Determine if perceptions change or remain the same
14. Determine if follow-up research is needed or if more questions develop as a result of the action research project
Mark Chambers
Diana Schumacher
Arts Leaders
NEISD Stakeholders
September 2011
New wonderings
Brainstorm